Book Review : The Hating Game by Sally Thorne

The Hating Game: A Novel

Author : Sally Thorne
Published By : William Morrow
Year Published : 2016
Genre / Tags : Romance, Contemporary
Mood : Light, fun, relaxing.
Formats : Hardcover, Paperback, eBook, Audiobook
# of Pages : 365 pages (Paperback)

Review

First, lets introduce the main characters-

Lucy – She’s a well-liked and sweet girl but also not afraid to speak her mind- which causes her to bump heads with one of the more incorrigible personalities at her workplace. I think most people will like Lucy. Career-driven but fun-loving. Playful but intelligent. Just a well-balanced character overall.

Joshua – This guy… where do I start. He’s a handful. Superbly fantastic-looking but with a blunt, abrasive personality. Thrives on conflict. He seems to have it in for Lucy. One thing I find interesting is that he shows some self-awareness toward the downsides of his personality and we see how that effects different areas of his life in a realistic way. But really, Josh is fun, he’s a challenge and at times infuriating yet consistently entertaining in his verbal sparring matches with Lucy. And he obviously adores her despite their many differences.

At one point I was trying to read this book in public, and had to put it aside because I kept smiling like an idiot. The Hating Game is perhaps the crème de la crème of guilty pleasures, and the first thing I want to make note of is the writing style. It’s really good, startlingly good. I would describe the writing, in comparison to many in the romance genre, as sharp and witty in a noteworthy way. The characters are rarely very stupid (they are a tad too old for that) and the level of angst is low despite this being a veritable minefield of potential drama.

This is an enemies to lovers / hate to love scenario replete with playful banter and a teasing, slow burn romance. The tension is extraordinary, at times frustrating, but was largely successful at keeping me engaged.

A frequent struggle with the #EnemiesToLovers scenario is the transition from enemies to lovers. I’ve rarely seen it done smoothly. Usually the couple just goes from hating each other in one moment to loving each other the next, it seems hard to pull off gradually and naturally. The Hating Game does quite skillfully manage to smoothly transition its couple from hating to liking and then loving each other, and still keeps some of their adversarial charm intact. They don’t conveniently change as people and do still have conflicts despite the growing affection.

Another thing about enemies to lovers is that it’s typically full of problematic, trigger warning-worthy happenings. The Hating Game is distinctive in managing to be not too controversial. It helps that the leads are on very level playing fields. I must confess, I’m not great at spotting content that people would popularly deem problematic. The goings-on in various foreign dramas and much older romance novels I’ve read before would make people’s hair fall out with the long lists of objectionable relationships and dodgy things that happen, lol. From my limited perspective, The Hating Game gives off a vibe that the author is being careful. Joshua a pretty decent guy. You know, outside of the two main characters wanting to comically destroy each other.

I can’t think of much to complain about, when observing what this book is trying to do. I think every area (the romance, the relationship, the banter, the will-they-or-won’t-they) is quite well done.

But as someone who usually reads romance as a companion piece to other genres lately, it did strike me how much of a keen focus there was on the main couple. Everything that ever happens in this book has to do with them and building upon their relationship. Very little, if any time is afforded to detailing friends/friendships or sub-plots that veer too far outside of the sphere of the couple’s interactions.

The plot can feel limited in some ways by this consistency. One might say “But Kitty, it’s a romance, of course everything is about the relationship!!” but I’ve read several romances in the past that develop meaningful friendships with other characters or back story or have some other side plot that offers variety. The Bridgerton series by Julia Quinn immediately comes to mind as one that not only develops side-plots but has a large family all doing their own things and gently leaving a mark on the reader. All while developing a narrative that does not lose sight of the main couple.

That said, The Hating Game has one job. Be a good romance novel. In that arena it delivers in spades. But for myself, reading this book alongside other books from other genres at the time was definitely helpful at keeping things fresh. I couldn’t see myself marathoning this one in a single sitting from beginning to end, but a more devoted romance reader or one who clicks in a special way with this couple might easily do so. I can imagine A LOT of people clicking with these two. They are brimming with charm.

Overall Rating – 9/10

Why You Should Try It – An enemies to lovers/hate to love scenario that is skillfully transitioned and just well handled. Sharp, witty writing and great banter. I found both characters very likable. Very fun and light atmosphere. Ideal beach read.

Why You Might Not Like It – The teasing nature of the slow burn romance can be annoying but the ending makes up for it. The chain of events is kind of short considering the size of this book (365 pages paperback.)

The Hating Game: A Novel (Amazon Link)

---

Have you read this book or are interested in reading it? Have you read anything else by Sally Thorne? Please feel free to share your thoughts, I read and appreciate all your comments and likes.